Reasoning · Grade 6-2 Loci and Traced Paths

Problem

Largest area a tied string can sweep

A paper equilateral triangle with 5 cm sides lies flat. A 7 cm string is tied to one corner with a pencil on the far end, and the pencil moves over the floor outside the paper. The string is kept taut as the pencil swings right round. Draw the figure of greatest area the pencil can trace.
5 cm
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Draw a Diagram — This is a drawing question, so the drawing is the answer, but the drawing is only right if I know where the pencil changes its turning point. Cut a triangle out of card, tape a 7 cm thread to one corner, and swing it: the thread turns freely about the anchor corner until it slams flat against a side, and from then on it pivots about the next corner with a shorter free end. That splits the whole sweep into subproblems -- one arc for each turning point -- and each subproblem only asks two questions: what is the radius, and how big is the turn?
1STEP 1

Name the corners and watch what the string does

Name the corners and follow the string.

2STEP 2

The big arc: radius 7 cm, turning 300 degrees

Round the tied corner it sweeps 300 degrees.

360° - 60° = 300° (radius 7 cm)
3STEP 3

What the string looks like the moment it catches

Once caught, 2 cm of string is left.

7 cm - 5 cm = 2 cm
4STEP 4

The small arc at B: radius 2 cm, turning 120 degrees

At that corner it sweeps 120 degrees.

180° - 60° = 120° (radius 2 cm)
5STEP 5

The same thing happens at C

The other corner does exactly the same.

180° - 60° = 120° (radius 2 cm)
6STEP 6

Show that the string stops there, and find the 1 cm the pencil never reaches

A middle 1 cm stays out of reach.

5 cm - 2 cm - 2 cm = 1 cm
7STEP 7

Draw the finished figure

The figure is three sectors joined.

8STEP 8

Check the total turning

The turning totals 540 degrees.

300° + 120° + 120° = 540°
Answer
one 7 cm sector and two 2 cm sectors
300 + 120 + 120 = 540
Every length in the picture is a length that really exists in the problem: 7 cm is the whole string, 2 cm is what is left after one side is used up, and 1 cm is the untouched middle of the far side. The region has to be a bit smaller than a full 7 cm circle, because the paper triangle steals a 60 degree wedge and gives back only two thin 2 cm sectors, and that is what the drawing shows. As a number check, the area is 49 x pi x 300/360 + 2 x (4 x pi x 120/360), which is 245/6 x pi + 16/6 x pi = 261/6 x pi = 43.5 x pi, about 137 square cm, comfortably less than a full 7 cm circle at 49 x pi, about 154 square cm, and comfortably more than a 5 cm circle at 25 x pi, about 79 square cm. The units are square centimetres for area and centimetres for every radius, as they should be.
Takeaway

Every time a taut string catches on a corner it loses one side length and swings again through the outside angle -- so just keep asking 'how long is left, and how far can it turn?'

  • Name the corners and watch what the string does
  • The big arc: radius 7 cm, turning 300 degrees
  • What the string looks like the moment it catches
  • The small arc at B: radius 2 cm, turning 120 degrees
  • The same thing happens at C
  • Show that the string stops there, and find the 1 cm the pencil never reaches
  • Draw the finished figure
  • Check the total turning