Reasoning · Grade 6-2 Loci and Traced Paths

Problem

Path length traced by a rolling triangle's vertex

An equilateral triangle with 2 cm sides stands on a 10 cm road. It tips to the right, always pivoting on the front corner. It rolls the whole length of the road. Find the path length traced by one corner.
A 2 cm 10 cm
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Draw a Diagram — Draw the triangle in every position it takes along the road and mark where A is each time; the arcs appear on the page and can be counted. Cutting a 2 cm triangle out of card, labelling one corner A, and tipping it along a ruler makes the trap impossible to miss: on one of the turns A is the corner doing the pivoting, so A stands still and contributes no arc at all. Then a short list -- one row per turn -- records the pivot corner, the radius and the angle, and adding the rows finishes the job.
1STEP 1

Count how many times the triangle tips over

The triangle tips 4 times.

(10 - 2) ÷ 2 = 4 tips
2STEP 2

What one tip does to a point of the triangle

Only the non-pivot corners move in a tip.

3STEP 3

How far the triangle turns in one tip: 120 degrees

Each tip turns 120 degrees.

180° - 60° = 120°
4STEP 4

List the four tips and see which one A sits out

In one of the four it is the pivot.

tip & pivot & A moves? ; 1 & C & yes, r=2, 120° ; 2 & A & no ; 3 & B & yes, r=2, 120° ; 4 & C & yes, r=2, 120°
5STEP 5

Check the pattern of which corner pivots

The pivot comes round in a regular pattern.

6STEP 6

Measure one arc

One arc is radius 2 cm through 120 degrees.

2 × 2 × 3.14 × 120°/360° (one arc)
7STEP 7

Add the three arcs

Three such arcs make 12.56 cm.

2 × 2 × 3.14 × 120°/360° × 3 = 12.56 (cm)
Answer
12.56 cm
4.186 × 3 = 12.56
The answer is a length in centimetres, which is what was asked. A rough size check: A ends up 10 - 1 = 9 cm to the right of where it started, and it got there along three curved humps rather than a straight line, so the path must be a fair bit longer than 9 cm. 12.56 cm is longer, but not wildly so -- each hump is only 2 cm tall at most, so the path cannot be anything like double the straight distance. The biggest risk in this problem is the count of arcs, so it is worth checking twice: 4 tips carry the triangle from 0-2 to 8-10, and the pivots cycle C, A, B, C, so A rests exactly once. Forgetting the resting tip and using 4 arcs would give 4 x 4.18... = about 16.75 cm, and dividing 10 by 2 to claim 5 tips would count a fifth tip that runs off the end of the road. Drawing the five positions on squared paper settles it.
Takeaway

When a shape rolls, the marked corner rests on the tips where it is the one doing the pivoting -- count those out before you add up any arcs.

  • Count how many times the triangle tips over
  • What one tip does to a point of the triangle
  • How far the triangle turns in one tip: 120 degrees
  • List the four tips and see which one A sits out
  • Check the pattern of which corner pivots
  • Measure one arc
  • Add the three arcs