Reasoning · Grade 6-1 Surface Area and Volume of Solids

Problem

Largest and smallest surface area

Six shapes use 4 unit cubes each. A: a row of 3 with 1 on top of an end; B: an L of 3 with 1 on the corner; C: an L of 3 with 1 on an end; D: a flat L of 4; E: a flat 2 by 2 square; F: a flat S of two offset pairs. Five have the same surface area; find the odd one out.
A B C D E F
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Make a Systematic List — Counting exposed squares by eye on six oblique drawings is exactly where mistakes happen, because the back and the underside are hidden in every picture. So I first solve the easier problem of two cubes and find the rule: each place where two cubes are joined hides 2 squares, one from each cube. That turns the whole question into a much safer one — for each shape, count the joins, which are all visible in the drawing. Then a short systematic list of six numbers settles it.
1STEP 1

Start with the cubes apart

Apart, the four cubes give 24.

4 × 6 = 24 square inches
2STEP 2

Find what one join costs

One join hides 2.

2 × 6 - 2 = 10 square inches
3STEP 3

Write the rule for any shape made of 4 cubes

So the area is 24 minus twice the joins.

S = 24 - 2 × (number of joins)
4STEP 4

Count the joins in each shape

Five shapes have 3 joins.

A: 3, B: 3, C: 3, D: 3, E: 4, F: 3
5STEP 5

Turn the joins into surface areas

Only E has 4 joins.

24 - 2 × 3 = 18, 24 - 2 × 4 = 16
6STEP 6

Say why E is special

So E's surface is 2 smaller.

18 - 16 = 2 square inches less
Answer
E
24 − 2 × 4 = 16
Shape E is a rectangular box measuring 2 inches by 2 inches by 1 inch, so its surface area can be found without any of the join reasoning: 2(2 x 2) + 2(2 x 1) + 2(2 x 1) = 8 + 4 + 4 = 16 square inches, which matches. Shape A contains a 1 by 1 by 3 row plus a cube; checking the row alone the same way gives 2(1 x 1) + 4(1 x 3) = 14 square inches, and adding a cube on top of an end covers 1 square and exposes 5, so 14 - 1 + 5 = 18 square inches, matching too. The magnitudes are sensible: 4 loose cubes give 24 square inches and a shape can never be worse than that, while the most tightly packed shape here, the 2 by 2 block, gives 16 — so every answer must lie between 16 and 24, and 16 and 18 both do. Units are square inches, correct for area, since each face is a 1 inch square.
Takeaway

Every place two cubes touch hides 2 square inches, so the shape with the most joins - the 2 by 2 block - has the smallest surface.

  • Start with the cubes apart
  • Find what one join costs
  • Write the rule for any shape made of 4 cubes
  • Count the joins in each shape
  • Turn the joins into surface areas
  • Say why E is special