Reasoning · Grade 4-2 Figure Puzzles

Problem

Move one piece to reshape an assembly

All seven tangram pieces make a rectangle twice as wide as it is tall. Three empty frames follow: a right triangle, a parallelogram and a trapezoid. Only one piece may be moved each time. Find which piece has to move.
A B C D E F G rectangle
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Draw a Diagram — Draw the rectangle on squared paper so every piece has corner coordinates, then draw the target shape on top of it. Whatever part of the target the rectangle does not already cover is exactly the hole the moved piece has to fill — so the moved piece is forced, and its size can be measured. That turns the puzzle into a genuinely finite check: there are only 7 candidate pieces, and comparing areas throws out 5 of them at once. Cutting the seven pieces out of paper and sliding them makes the last step obvious.
1STEP 1

Measure every piece on the 8-by-4 frame

The seven pieces total 32.

8 + 8 + 4 + 4 + 4 + 2 + 2 = 32 = 8 × 4
2STEP 2

Every shape in the chain has area 32

The three target shapes also have area 32.

1/2 × 8 × 8 = 32
3STEP 3

Lay the target right triangle over the rectangle and see what is left over

Overlaying shows the area to move is 8.

32 - 8 = 24 shared, area to move = 8
4STEP 4

Only two of the seven pieces are big enough

Only the two large triangles have area 8.

A = 8, G = 8; B = D = 2, C = E = F = 4
5STEP 5

Move the same large triangle again to get the parallelogram

Moving the same triangle again gives the parallelogram.

base 8 × height 4 = 32
6STEP 6

Move it once more to get the trapezoid

Once more gives the trapezoid.

1/2 × (4 + 12) × 4 = 32
7STEP 7

Why no smaller piece could ever do the job

Smaller pieces are too small, so it is the large right triangle.

8 > 4 > 2
Answer
one large right triangle
32 − 24 = 8
Every outline in the chain was checked to have area 32, the same as the 8 x 4 rectangle, so no paper appears or disappears. Each target was checked against its definition: the first has a square corner at (0, 4); the second has two pairs of parallel sides but no square corner, so it is a parallelogram and not a rectangle; the third has only the top and bottom parallel, so it is a trapezoid and not a parallelogram. The moved piece is a right triangle with legs 4 in all three placements, so it slots into each hole exactly with no gap and no overlap.
Takeaway

Lay the new shape on top of the old one — the leftover bit tells you exactly which piece has to move, and here only a big triangle is large enough.

  • Measure every piece on the 8-by-4 frame
  • Every shape in the chain has area 32
  • Lay the target right triangle over the rectangle and see what is left over
  • Only two of the seven pieces are big enough
  • Move the same large triangle again to get the parallelogram
  • Move it once more to get the trapezoid
  • Why no smaller piece could ever do the job