Reasoning · Grade 4-2 Figure Puzzles

Problem

Cut a hexagon with two straight lines

Six identical regular-hexagon sheets are given. On each, draw exactly 2 straight lines right across and cut along both. The pieces must match the list set for that hexagon exactly, such as “4 trapezoids” or “2 triangles and 2 rhombuses”. Find the two cuts for each of the six.
(1) 2 triangles 1 trapezoid (2) 4 trapezoids (3) 2 triangles 2 rhombuses (4) 2 trapezoids 1 hexagon (5) 1 triangle 3 trapezoids (6) 1 triangle 1 trapezoid 1 parallelogram 1 pentagon
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Draw a Diagram — There is nothing to calculate here — the answer is a drawing — so the work is to stop guessing and start choosing the cuts on purpose. Two things make that possible. First, count the pieces: 3 pieces means the two cuts must miss each other inside the hexagon, 4 pieces means they must cross inside it, and that immediately sorts the six lists into two families. Second, notice that this hexagon is full of parallel lines — opposite sides are parallel and every long diagonal is parallel to two sides — so a cut placed along or parallel to one of those directions is guaranteed to hand back trapezoids and parallelograms rather than random four-sided pieces. The example, condition (1), is the easy related problem that shows how the two ideas work together, so I read the method off it first and then apply it five more times.
1STEP 1

Read the counting rule off the example

The example falls into 3 pieces.

(1) 2+1=3, (2) 4, (3) 2+2=4, (4) 2+1=3, (5) 1+3=4, (6) 1+1+1+1=4
2STEP 2

List the directions that are worth cutting along

The useful cuts are diagonals and lines parallel to a side.

3STEP 3

(1) Check the example: 2 triangles and 1 trapezoid

For (1), two diagonals from one vertex give 3 pieces.

cuts E - B, E - C → △ EBC, △ ECD, trapezoid ABEF
4STEP 4

(2) Four trapezoids

For (2), a long diagonal and a crossing line give 4 trapezoids.

cuts F - C, M - N → MAFO, MBCO, ONDC, OFEN
5STEP 5

(3) Two triangles and two rhombuses

For (3), two long diagonals give 2 triangles and 2 rhombuses.

cuts F - C, A - D → △ OAF, △ OCD, rhombus OABC, rhombus OFED
6STEP 6

(4) Two trapezoids and one hexagon

For (4), two lines parallel to a side give 3 pieces.

two cuts ∥ BC → trapezoid PBCQ, trapezoid RFES, hexagon APQDSR
7STEP 7

(5) One triangle and three trapezoids

For (5) the cuts give 1 triangle and 3 trapezoids.

cuts A - D, F - M → △ AXF, ABMX, XMCD, XDEF
8STEP 8

(6) One triangle, one trapezoid, one parallelogram and one pentagon

For (6) the four pieces are all different shapes.

cuts B - E, P - Q ∥ BC → △ PBX, parallelogram XBCQ, trapezoid XQDE, pentagon APXEF
9STEP 9

Check every drawing against its list

All six sheets match their lists.

Answer
3, 4, 4, 3, 4, 4 pieces
2 + 1 = 3, 2 + 2 = 4
Every answer is a drawing, so the checks are counting checks. First, the number of pieces on each sheet agrees with the list (3, 4, 4, 3, 4, 4), and in each case the cuts cross inside the hexagon exactly when 4 pieces were required. Second, adding the pieces back together must recover the whole hexagon, and it does: for instance in (3) the two rhombuses each cover a third of the hexagon and the two triangles a sixth each, and 1/3+1/3+1/6+1/6 = 1. Third, the corner counts are right: 3 for every triangle, 4 for every trapezoid, parallelogram and rhombus, 5 for the pentagon in (6) and 6 for the hexagon in (4). Notice too that (4) is the only list with a six-sided piece, and it is the only one whose cuts both miss all six vertices — which is exactly what has to happen for the middle piece to keep six corners.
Takeaway

Decide first whether the two cuts should cross inside the shape or not, then aim them along the hexagon's own parallel lines — that is what makes the pieces come out with the names you were asked for.

  • Read the counting rule off the example
  • List the directions that are worth cutting along
  • (1) Check the example: 2 triangles and 1 trapezoid
  • (2) Four trapezoids
  • (3) Two triangles and two rhombuses
  • (4) Two trapezoids and one hexagon
  • (5) One triangle and three trapezoids
  • (6) One triangle, one trapezoid, one parallelogram and one pentagon
  • Check every drawing against its list