Reasoning · Grade 4-1 Clocks and Angles

Problem

Times whose clock-hand angle is acute

Six times are given: 8:00, 3:30, 5:10, 7:50, 2:55 and 11:15. For each, take the smaller of the two angles between the hands. An acute angle is less than 90 degrees. Pick out every time whose angle is acute.
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Draw a Diagram — Angles on a clock are much easier to trust when they are drawn, so for each time I picture where the two hands actually point. To turn the picture into a number I first fix the units: one hour mark is worth 30 degrees, and I work out how far the hour hand has crept past its hour mark. Then I run the same short calculation on all six times in a table, rather than eyeballing the ones that look obvious, because the near-90-degree cases are exactly where guessing goes wrong.
1STEP 1

Find what one hour mark is worth in degrees

One hour mark is 30 degrees.

360° ÷ 12 = 30°
2STEP 2

Work out how far the hour hand creeps in one hour

The hour hand creeps one mark per hour.

m/60 × 30°, 30/60 × 30° = 15°, 10/60 × 30° = 5°
3STEP 3

Fix a way to measure both hands from 12

Measure both hands from 12.

minute = 6° × m, hour = 30° × h + m/60 × 30°
4STEP 4

Check 8:00

8:00 gives 120 degrees.

4 × 30° = 120°
5STEP 5

Check 3:30 — the hour hand has moved half a gap

3:30 gives 75 degrees, acute.

180° - (90° + 15°) = 75°
6STEP 6

Check 5:10 — the near miss

5:10 gives 95 degrees — just over.

(150° + 5°) - 60° = 95°
7STEP 7

Check 7:50

7:50 gives 65 degrees, acute.

300° - (210° + 25°) = 65°
8STEP 8

Check 2:55

2:55 gives 117.5 degrees.

360° - (330° - 87.5°) = 117.5°
9STEP 9

Check 11:15

11:15 gives 112.5 degrees.

360° - (337.5° - 90°) = 112.5°
10STEP 10

Collect the acute ones

The acute ones are 3:30 and 7:50.

75° < 90°, 65° < 90°
Answer
3:30, 7:50
75 degrees, 65 degrees
Every angle came out between 0 and 180 degrees, which is right for the smaller of the two angles between two rays. Sketching each clock confirms the sizes: at 8:00 the hands are clearly more than a quarter-turn apart, while at 7:50 the hour hand has almost reached 8 and the minute hand is on 10, barely two hour marks away, so a small angle like 65 degrees is believable. The two near misses land on opposite sides of 90 by only 5 degrees each (75 and 95), which is exactly the trap the problem sets, and both were settled by calculation rather than by eye.
Takeaway

The short hand never waits on the number — it creeps forward all hour, and that little creep is what decides the close calls!

  • Find what one hour mark is worth in degrees
  • Work out how far the hour hand creeps in one hour
  • Fix a way to measure both hands from 12
  • Check 8:00
  • Check 3:30 — the hour hand has moved half a gap
  • Check 5:10 — the near miss
  • Check 7:50
  • Check 2:55
  • Check 11:15
  • Collect the acute ones