Reasoning · Grade 6-1 Distance and Speed (2)

Problem

Boat speed with and against a current

The boat would do 10 miles per hour on still water. The river itself slides along at 4 miles per hour. The speed seen from the bank depends on the direction. Find the time each way, downstream and upstream.
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Draw a Diagram — Draw the river with a big arrow for the current and a small arrow on the boat, and the addition and subtraction stop being something to memorize: when the two arrows point the same way the lengths pile up, and when they point opposite ways they cancel. Then a one-hour thought experiment (tool 9) settles the number — ask only 'how far down the bank does the boat get in ONE hour?' — and after that the units do the rest: miles divided by miles-per-hour gives hours.
1STEP 1

Picture what the current does in one hour

The current carries the boat 4 further an hour.

2STEP 2

(1) Downstream: the two arrows point the same way, so add

Downstream the speed is 14.

10 + 4 = 14 miles per hour (downstream)
3STEP 3

(1) Divide the 70 miles by the downstream speed

Dividing gives 5 hours.

70 ÷ 14 = 5 hours
4STEP 4

(2) Upstream: the arrows fight, so subtract

Upstream the speed is 6.

10 - 4 = 6 miles per hour (upstream)
5STEP 5

(2) Divide the 90 miles by the upstream speed

Dividing gives 15 hours.

90 ÷ 6 = 15 hours
6STEP 6

Check both answers by multiplying back

Multiplying back confirms both.

14 × 5 = 70 ✓ 6 × 15 = 90 ✓
Answer
5, 15 hours
70 ÷ 14 = 5, 90 ÷ 6 = 15
Units are right: miles divided by miles-per-hour leaves hours in both parts. The sizes make sense too. Downstream the boat is faster than its still-water 10 miles per hour, so 70 miles should take less than 70 / 10 = 7 hours — and 5 hours does. Upstream it is slower than 10, so 90 miles should take more than 90 / 10 = 9 hours — and 15 hours does. The contrast is the real sanity check: the upstream trip is only about 29% longer in distance (90 against 70) but takes three times as long, which is exactly what a 14-versus-6 speed gap predicts. Had the still-water 10 been used for both, the answers would have been 7 and 9 hours, which would wrongly make the two directions look almost equally easy.
Takeaway

The river moves the boat too: add the current when you go with it, subtract it when you go against it, and only then divide the distance by that speed.

  • Picture what the current does in one hour
  • (1) Downstream: the two arrows point the same way, so add
  • (1) Divide the 70 miles by the downstream speed
  • (2) Upstream: the arrows fight, so subtract
  • (2) Divide the 90 miles by the upstream speed
  • Check both answers by multiplying back