Reasoning · Grade 4-2 Figure Puzzles

Problem

Shape of the overlap of two figures

Two squares of exactly the same size are laid one over the other. Only the part they share is shaded. Three cases are given: the overlap is a triangle, a quadrilateral, a pentagon. Find a placement for each case.
triangle quadrilateral pentagon
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Create a Physical Representation — Cutting two identical paper squares and sliding one across the other is the quickest way to see what controls the number of sides of the shared part: hold one square still and move only the other, exactly as the book's note advises, and watch how many corners land inside and how many edges cross. That experiment gives a counting rule for the sides of the overlap. Then I work backwards from each given shape — its corners tell me how many corners must land inside and how many edges must cross — and finally I draw the placement and check it.
1STEP 1

Cut two identical squares and watch what makes the corners of the overlap

Overlap corners are corners inside plus side crossings.

sides of the overlap = (corners that landed inside) + (places where two sides cross)
2STEP 2

Work backwards from the triangle: 3 corners means 1 corner inside and 2 crossings

A triangle needs 1 corner inside.

1 + 2 = 3
3STEP 3

Draw the triangle placement

Let just one corner poke into the other square.

4STEP 4

Work backwards from the quadrilateral: one corner of each square inside, plus 2 crossings

A quadrilateral needs one corner from each.

1 + 1 + 2 = 4
5STEP 5

Draw the quadrilateral placement

Overlap the two squares at a slant.

6STEP 6

Work backwards from the pentagon: 2 corners of one square inside, 1 of the other, and 2 crossings

A pentagon needs 3 corners inside in total.

2 + 1 + 2 = 5
7STEP 7

Draw the pentagon placement

Push in far enough for two corners of one square.

8STEP 8

Check every drawing

All three drawings match their cases.

Answer
1, 2 and 3 corners inside
1 + 2 = 3, 2 + 2 = 4, 3 + 2 = 5
The counting rule matches every drawing: 1 corner inside + 2 crossings = 3 sides, 1 + 1 corners inside + 2 crossings = 4 sides, 2 + 1 corners inside + 2 crossings = 5 sides. It also agrees with the extreme cases you can check on paper: lay one square exactly on top of the other and the overlap is the square itself, 4 sides; turn one square into a diamond about the same centre and the overlap is an eight-sided figure, because no corner is inside and the edges cross 8 times. So an overlap of two squares always has between 3 and 8 sides, and 3, 4 and 5 sit comfortably inside that range. Each drawn overlap is convex and covers less area than one whole square, as it must.
Takeaway

Every corner of the shared part is either a corner that slipped inside or a place where two edges cross — count those and you know how many sides the overlap will have.

  • Cut two identical squares and watch what makes the corners of the overlap
  • Work backwards from the triangle: 3 corners means 1 corner inside and 2 crossings
  • Draw the triangle placement
  • Work backwards from the quadrilateral: one corner of each square inside, plus 2 crossings
  • Draw the quadrilateral placement
  • Work backwards from the pentagon: 2 corners of one square inside, 1 of the other, and 2 crossings
  • Draw the pentagon placement
  • Check every drawing