Reasoning · Grade 4-1 Joining and Cutting Figures

Problem

Join unlike shapes edge to edge

There are two identical small equilateral triangles and one isosceles trapezoid. The trapezoid is itself three of those triangles joined. Use all three pieces, matching a whole side to a whole side of equal length. Count how many different shapes can be made.
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Make a Systematic List — The trapezoid is the biggest piece, so I hold it still and treat it as the base. Then the only decisions left are where each triangle goes, and there are very few places for them because most of the trapezoid's border is the wrong length. Listing those few places in a fixed order guarantees nothing is missed, and cutting the pieces out of paper, or just sketching each result, makes it easy to spot which arrangements are really the same shape turned or flipped over.
1STEP 1

Measure the sides and find out where a triangle can be attached

By side length a triangle fits only the trapezoid's short sides.

1 + 1 = 2 ≠ 1
2STEP 2

Notice that the trapezoid has a mirror symmetry

The trapezoid is mirror-symmetric, so left and right are the same spot.

3STEP 3

Case 1, both triangles glued straight onto the trapezoid

Both triangles on the trapezoid give 2 shapes.

{L,R}, {L,T}, {T,R} → 2 shapes
4STEP 4

Case 2, one triangle on the trapezoid and the second triangle on the first

Chaining one triangle onto the other adds only 1 shape.

3 × 2 = 6 arrangements → 1 new shape
5STEP 5

Collect the different shapes

Together that is 2 + 1 = 3.

2 + 1 = 3
Answer
3 shapes
2 + 1 = 3
Every finished figure is made of exactly 5 small triangles, since the trapezoid is worth 3 and the two loose triangles are worth 1 each, so all three answers have the same area, which is a good sign that nothing was double counted or lost. Three is also a believable size for the answer: there are only a handful of places to attach anything, and turning and flipping merges several of them. It is worth noticing that a fourth five-triangle figure does exist on paper, the fan of five triangles all meeting at one point, but building it would need a triangle glued to only half of the trapezoid's 2 unit bottom side, which the matching rule forbids.
Takeaway

Check which sides are even allowed to meet first, then turn and flip each new figure to see whether you have already made it.

  • Measure the sides and find out where a triangle can be attached
  • Notice that the trapezoid has a mirror symmetry
  • Case 1, both triangles glued straight onto the trapezoid
  • Case 2, one triangle on the trapezoid and the second triangle on the first
  • Collect the different shapes