Reasoning · Grade 2-2 Bars and Length

Problem

Counting Measurable Lengths

A short bar is 3 cm wide, a long bar 8 cm, and both are 1 cm thick. A bar's 1 cm thickness may also be used to measure. Pieces can be laid end to end to add, or lined up so the leftover reads as a difference. Count how many different lengths can be measured.
3 cm 1 cm 8 cm 1 cm
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Make a Systematic List — The building blocks are the lengths 1, 3, and 8 (with two 1 cm thicknesses available). By drawing how bars line up — end to end to add, or aligned to read the difference — we can list every length from the smallest up to the longest and check none is missed and none repeats.
1STEP 1

List the basic lengths the bars give

Laid down as they are, the bars give 1, 3, 8.

1, 3, 8
2STEP 2

Make new lengths by adding pieces end to end

Adding end to end gives 4, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13.

3+1=4, 8+1=9, 3+8=11, 8+1+1=10, 3+8+1=12, 3+8+1+1=13
3STEP 3

Make new lengths by reading the difference

Reading the leftovers fills in 2, 5, 6, 7.

3-1=2, 8-1=7, 8-3=5, 8+1-3=6
4STEP 4

Collect every distinct length

Together that is 1 through 13 with no gaps — 13 lengths.

1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13 → 13 lengths
Answer
13 lengths (1 cm through 13 cm)
The longest possible length is all four pieces end to end, 3 + 8 + 1 + 1 = 13 cm, and the shortest is the 1 cm thickness, so any measurable length lies between 1 and 13. We exhibited a way to make every whole centimetre 1, 2, …, 13, so exactly 13 different lengths are possible — the largest the answer could be.
Takeaway

By adding and comparing the bars (and their 1 cm thickness!), you can make every length from 1 to 13 cm — just Grade 2 add-and-compare thinking!

  • List the basic lengths the bars give
  • Make new lengths by adding pieces end to end
  • Make new lengths by reading the difference
  • Collect every distinct length