Reasoning · Grade 2-1 Attributes and Reasoning

Problem

Chain attribute cards by one-attribute change

A shape is described by three attributes: shape, pattern (striped or plain) and size (large or small). The reference is a large striped circle, with four choices beside it. Find the one choice that differs in all three attributes.
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Make a Systematic List — There are only four choices and three attributes, so we make a small table that checks each choice against the reference attribute by attribute, then eliminate any choice that shares even one attribute with the reference.
1STEP 1

Write down the reference attributes

The reference is circle, striped, large, so the answer must reverse all three.

2STEP 2

Check ㉠ (large plain square)

㉠ differs in shape and pattern but matches on size, so it is out.

3STEP 3

Check ㉡ (small plain triangle)

㉡ is triangle, plain, small — all three differ.

4STEP 4

Check ㉢ and ㉣ to be sure ㉡ is the only one

㉢ matches the pattern and ㉣ the shape, so is the only answer.

Answer
triangle, plain, small
Exactly one choice survives the all-three-different test: ㉠ keeps the size, ㉢ keeps the pattern, ㉣ keeps the shape, and only ㉡ differs in shape, pattern, and size. A well-posed 'find the one that differs in everything' problem should have a single answer, which matches.
Takeaway

To be different in every way, a shape must lose its match on shape, pattern, AND size — just one matching attribute knocks it out!

  • Write down the reference attributes
  • Check ㉠ (large plain square)
  • Check ㉡ (small plain triangle)
  • Check ㉢ and ㉣ to be sure ㉡ is the only one