Reasoning · Grade 2-1 Measurable Lengths

Problem

Reachable lengths from given bars

Four bars of length 1 cm, 3 cm, 4 cm and 11 cm are hinged into one chain. At each hinge a bar either keeps going forward or folds straight back over the one before it. The measured length is the distance from the very first end to the very last end. Find every different length the chain can make.
3 cm 1 cm 11 cm 4 cm
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Make a Systematic List — Folding a bar back means subtracting its length, and extending it means adding its length, so every setting is one choice of + or - in front of each bar: 1 ± 3 ± 4 ± 11. There are only a handful of sign choices, so we list them all in an orderly way, take the size of each total, and keep the different positive results.
1STEP 1

Turn folding into plus and minus

Forward adds and folding subtracts, so the end lands at 1 ± 3 ± 4 ± 11.

1 ± 3 ± 4 ± 11
2STEP 2

List the totals with the 4 cm and 11 cm bars BOTH forward

With both 4 and 11 forward we get 19 and 13.

1+3+4+11=19, 1-3+4+11=13
3STEP 3

List the totals with the 11 cm bar forward but the 4 cm bar folded

With 11 forward but 4 folded we get 11 and 5.

1+3-4+11=11, 1-3-4+11=5
4STEP 4

List the totals with the 11 cm bar folded back

Folding the 11 gives -3, -9, -11, -17, which as distances are 3, 9, 11, 17.

1+3+4-11=-3, 1-3+4-11=-9, 1+3-4-11=-11, 1-3-4-11=-17
5STEP 5

Collect the different lengths

Counting the repeated 11 once leaves seven: 3, 5, 9, 11, 13, 17, 19.

{3, 5, 9, 11, 13, 17, 19} cm
Answer
3, 5, 9, 11, 13, 17, 19 cm (7 lengths)
Every length is between the most folded case and the all-forward case. The largest, 19 cm, is exactly 1+3+4+11, the longest the chain can reach. The smallest, 3 cm, comes from 11-(1+3+4)=11-8=3, the closest the ends can get without overlapping into a negative we'd already counted. All seven answers fall inside this 3-to-19 range, so they are reasonable.
Takeaway

Folding a stick back just subtracts its length - so with a few neat plus-or-minus tries you can list every length the ruler can make, using only Grade 2 adding and subtracting!

  • Turn folding into plus and minus
  • List the totals with the 4 cm and 11 cm bars BOTH forward
  • List the totals with the 11 cm bar forward but the 4 cm bar folded
  • List the totals with the 11 cm bar folded back
  • Collect the different lengths