Reasoning · Grade 2-1 Measuring Length with Units

Problem

Measure one length in different units

A desk's width is measured two ways. One way it is 3 long pencils and 6 short pencils, the other way it is 6 long pencils and 2 short pencils. Both measure the very same width, so find how many short pencils match 12 long pencils.
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Guess and Check — Both pencil-trains measure the same width, so they balance like a see-saw. By comparing the two trains I can trade away the pencils that appear in both and discover a simple swap rule: a fixed number of long pencils equals a fixed number of short pencils. Once I know that one trade, I can scale it up to 12 long pencils. I prefer a concrete 'balance and check' approach over algebra because a 2nd grader can act it out with real pencils.
1STEP 1

Set the two trains equal

Both trains measure the same width, so they are equal in length.

3 long + 6 short = 6 long + 2 short
2STEP 2

Take the same pencils off both sides

Take off the shared 3 long and 2 short from both sides and 4 short = 3 long is left.

6 short - 2 short = 6 long - 3 long → 4 short = 3 long
3STEP 3

Find the trade rule

That is the trade rule — 3 long pencils always swap for 4 short.

3 long = 4 short
4STEP 4

Scale up to 12 long pencils

12 makes four groups of 3, so 4 × 4 = 16.

12 ÷ 3 = 4 groups, 4 × 4 = 16 short
Answer
16 short pencils
12 ÷ 3 = 4, 4 × 4 = 16
Short pencils are shorter than long pencils, so it should take MORE short pencils than long pencils to reach the same length — and indeed 16 short > 12 long. Checking the trade: 3 long = 4 short means each long pencil is 4/3 of a short pencil, so 12 long = 12 × 4/3 = 16 short. Both views of the desk also agree: 3 long + 6 short = 4 short + 6 short... using 3 long = 4 short gives 10 short, and 6 long + 2 short = 8 short + 2 short = 10 short. They match.
Takeaway

When two rulers measure the same length, take away the parts they share — what is left tells you the fair trade between long and short!

  • Set the two trains equal
  • Take the same pencils off both sides
  • Find the trade rule
  • Scale up to 12 long pencils