Reasoning · Grade 5-2 Exploring the Cube

Problem

Cross-sections cut from a cube

Seven identical cubes each carry 20 dots. Eight at the corners and twelve at the edge midpoints. Each cube is cut once by a flat plane through some dots. Make the exposed face take each of the seven named shapes.
an equilateral triangle an isosceles triangle that is not equilateral a square a rectangle that is not a square a trapezoid that is not a rectangle a rhombus that is not a square a regular hexagon
Your answer
How to solve
Strategy Visualize Spatial Relationships — Guessing planes at random is hopeless; what steers the search is one rule — the number of sides of the cross-section equals the number of faces the plane cuts through. So I decide the number of sides first (3, 4 or 6), which tells me how many faces to aim at, and only then look for the particular plane. Two more rules do the rest: sides lying in opposite faces come out parallel, and equal-looking sides really are equal whenever the cube's own symmetry swaps them. Naming the eight vertices lets me write each answer as a short list of points instead of a vague description, and slicing a real eraser or a lump of clay is the check the book itself recommends.
1STEP 1

Name the corners so every cut can be written down

Give the corners names so cuts can be written down.

2STEP 2

The key rule: sides come from faces, one side per face

One side appears per face crossed.

number of sides = number of faces the plane cuts, 3 ≤ sides ≤ 6
3STEP 3

Shape 1 — equilateral triangle: slice a corner off

Slicing a corner gives an equilateral triangle.

△ BDG: BD = DG = GB = face diagonal
4STEP 4

Shape 2 — isosceles but not equilateral: slide one corner of that triangle down

Sliding one corner down gives an isosceles triangle.

BM_CG = DM_CG = √(2²+1²) = √(5), BD = √(2²+2²) = 2√(2) ≠ √(5)
5STEP 5

Shape 3 — square: cut straight across the middle

A straight middle cut gives a square.

each side = edge, each angle = 90°
6STEP 6

Shape 4 — rectangle that is not a square: cut through two opposite edges

Through two opposite edges gives a rectangle.

FG = AD = 2, GD = FA = 2√(2), 2 ≠ 2√(2)
7STEP 7

Shape 5 — trapezoid that is not a rectangle: one long parallel side and one short one

Unequal parallel sides give a trapezoid.

M_ABM_AD = 1/2BD = 1/2FH, √(2) ≠ 2√(2)
8STEP 8

Shape 6 — rhombus that is not a square: cut along a cube diagonal

Cutting along a body diagonal gives a rhombus.

FM_CG = M_CGD = DM_AE = M_AEF = √(5); FD = 2√(3) ≠ 2√(2) = M_CGM_AE
9STEP 9

Shape 7 — regular hexagon: hit all six faces at once

Hitting all six faces gives a regular hexagon.

each side = 1/2×face diagonal = √(2) (edge 2)
10STEP 10

Slice a real cube to check every one

Slicing for real shows all seven work.

Answer
all seven are possible
3, 4, 5, 6
Every one of the seven cuts uses only marked points — corners and edge midpoints — as required, and every side count is possible for a cube: 3, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4 and 6 faces cut, never more than the 6 faces available. The 'not' conditions are all checked by an actual comparison rather than by eye: cut 2 has √(5) ≠ 2√(2), so it is not equilateral; cut 4 has 2 ≠ 2√(2), so it is not a square; cut 5 has parallel sides √(2) and 2√(2), so it is not a parallelogram and therefore not a rectangle; cut 6 has unequal diagonals 2√(3) and 2√(2), so it is a rhombus and not a square. The side rule also tells you where the limits are: because a plane meets each flat face in at most one segment and a cube has only 6 faces, a cross-section of a cube can never have 7 or more sides — a heptagonal cross-section is impossible, and so is any shape needing two separate cuts of the same face.
Takeaway

Count faces, not corners: whichever faces your flat cut passes through become the sides of the cross-section, so a cube can give you three, four, five or six sides - and never more than six.

  • Name the corners so every cut can be written down
  • The key rule: sides come from faces, one side per face
  • Shape 1 — equilateral triangle: slice a corner off
  • Shape 2 — isosceles but not equilateral: slide one corner of that triangle down
  • Shape 3 — square: cut straight across the middle
  • Shape 4 — rectangle that is not a square: cut through two opposite edges
  • Shape 5 — trapezoid that is not a rectangle: one long parallel side and one short one
  • Shape 6 — rhombus that is not a square: cut along a cube diagonal
  • Shape 7 — regular hexagon: hit all six faces at once
  • Slice a real cube to check every one